Minutes of Committee Meeting 8th Jan 2018
Minutes of Committee Meeting 6th Nov 2017
Minutes of Committee Meeting 2nd Oct 2017
Minutes of Committee Meeting 9th Sept 2017
Minutes of Committee Meeting 14th Aug 2017
Minutes of Committee Meeting 15th May 2017
Minutes of Committee Meeting 20th March2017
Draft Minutes of AGM 30 October 2017
Minutes of the SGM 22nd August 2016
Minutes of AGM November 7th 2016
Minutes of AGM 29th October 2015
Minutes of AGM 23rd October 2014
Minutes of AGM 17th October 2013
BRIDGE NIGHT CANCELLATION
There are occasions, particularly during the winter months, when it may be necessary to cancel a club night at short notice. To avoid making an unnecessary journey please check your email, or if you do not have email, contact the Committee Member who has primary responsibility for that evening :
• Monday: John Whiteside 01291 408617
• Wednesday: Sue Blake 01291 624233
• Thursday: John Mayo 01594 530553
If you are unable to contact the above, contact any of the Committee Members.
Top of Page
DRAFT MINUTES OF AGM 30TH OCTOBER 2017
An Attendance Sheet recording the arrival of the members at the AGM recorded the attendance of forty-one members and a representative of the Social players present.
1. Apologies for Absence – Nine apologies had been received by the Secretary prior to the meeting and a further four were received at the meeting.
2. John Mayo (JM) opened the meeting by welcoming everyone to the AGM. He stated the different people saw his position in the club differently and there was some debate as to whether he was currently – just a committee member, Deputy Chairman, Acting Chairman or Chairman. As the last Chairman had resigned someone has got to run the AGM. He stated his willingness to serve as Chairman, as long as the majority of the members were happy for him to do so. JM was therefore altering the order of the agenda so that the meeting could vote for or against him and the other committee members and so that the meeting could proceed with a committee that had the full backing of the members. If, however, they felt that he was the wrong person for the job he would happily stand down and let someone else try to sort things out. He stated that if the membership did vote for him as Chairman he would like to think that the membership would support the suggestions that he and rest of the committee put forward, otherwise it was a pointless exercise.
3. Chairman’s Report – JM stated that he would only deal with what had happened since he had been acting as Chairman. JM reported that the last year or so had been an unhappy time for the club away from the bridge tables. Marion had resigned from the role of treasurer, after many years of dedicated service. Peter Taylor, who had spent a considerable amount of time and effort trying to steer the Club through a very difficult period resigned the Chairmanship. On the Club’s behalf he wished to thank them both for their past service. Subsequently the remaining members of the committee have done their best to come up with a way forward and JM thought it fair to say that all the decisions reached were unanimous, or at the least, almost so, and that anything the Committee were proposing had the backing of them all. JM stated that it was impossible to please everyone all the time, but he hoped that the decisions taken that evening would be accepted by all the members so that we can all forget about “crossing the Ts and dotting the Is”, worrying about small print and concentrate on playing bridge in convivial company.
4. Election of Officers and Committee Members – JM informed the meeting that there would be one less member on the Committee this year as Ian Wood was standing down, and the Committee would revert to the numbers of members in place two years ago and as stated in the Club Rules. JM stated that all the Officers and Committee Members seeking re-election had been proposed and seconded by members of the club and that he would ask the meeting to elect each of the Officers, individually, followed by the re-election of the existing committee members and the election of the two new members. Following the individual votes, the Officers and members of the Committee were unanimously elected.
5. JM said that before the meeting moved on to the next item on the agenda he wished to mention that the Committee had received a proposition from Peter Smith (PS) that social players should pay £1.00 more table money than members. This subject had already been an ongoing topic at Committee meetings for some time. PS withdrew his proposition after the Committee included the differential in the Bye-Laws. However, it remained a controversial decision and JM asked for an informal show of hands to see what support there was for the differential – it would not be binding, but if the majority voted against the increase JM would ensure that it was brought up again at the next committee. JM asked for the show of hands, and a majority voted in favour of the change.
6. Minutes of the SGM 22nd August 2016 – PS stated that they were incomplete as both the proposals presented at the meeting were not attached to the MInutes. Peter Taylor (PT) stated that the complete document had been published on the Club’s website for over a year. The Chairman asked the meeting to vote on acceptance of the Minutes. There was a very substantial majority if favour of accepting the SGM Minutes.
7. Minutes of the AGM 7th November 2016 – PS stated that the amended Rules of the club were incorrect and they did not mention the Social Players. JM said that the Social Players were not members of the Club so were not governed by the Rules, but by the Bye-Laws which had been amended to include matters relating to Social Players. Marion Shewell (MS) asked why there had been a change to Point 8 In the Rules – general meeting of the Club from October or November to “on a date to be fixed by the committee”. Did this mean that the AGM would be moved to end of the year instead of the current period . JM responded that the AGM would take place within the current time frame and that it was not necessary to move it. MS did not agree. PS was not in agreement with the amended Rules and offered to review them again and present them at another meeting. JM stated that the Committee were very grateful for all the work that PS had done on the Rules over the last year or two, but, the members would be asked to vote on the document put before them at this AGM. The AGM Minutes were overwhelmingly accepted by the membership.
8. Matters Arising –
i) Social representative – JM invited Stewart Anderton (SA) a representative of the social players to address the meeting. SA explained that the social players were not a cohesive group, but individuals who were very dissatisfied with the behaviour and performance of the WBU , especially the problems caused to clubs in the region by their decision that all clubs had to be affiliated to WBU. The increase in table money was very disappointing. Some players would have been prepared to make a donation to the club, but were not prepared to pay funds to the WBU. SA did not feel that they were a drain on the club finances, but were contributing to the profits of the club.
ii) The updated Bye-Laws for the Conduct and Affairs of the Club were presented at the meeting, including the fact that there would be no requirement for members following their 90th birthday (who been continuous members for at least ten years) to pay an annual club subscription. Doreen Griffiths asked if that included WBU membership and this was confirmed. There was also a query regarding the number of times that Visitors could play at the club before being asked to become members. JM agreed that there was no particular logic to the number, that it had been in the Bye-Laws for some time, but that he felt this was a matter of discretion for the Committee. Bridget Evans suggested that the members should put their trust in the Committee to do what was necessary, and this was met with approval by the members.
9. Treasurers Report – John Whiteside (JW) thanked Marion for her hard work as Treasurer. He informed the meeting that he had opened a Bank Account with Barclays for the Club and this would mean that the account could be managed on-line, and that he would be able to write cheques for payments by the Club. He went on to say that attendance at Club evenings had dropped this year, and there had been occasions, particularly on a Wednesday evening when there had been as few as 3 tables. In the long term this would be unsustainable and JW will monitor the situation. JW also informed the meeting that he understood that The Palmer Centre were going to undertake a review of rental charges (this was confirmed by Marjorie Terrill) and whilst the rent charged to the Club was very reasonable, an increase instituted by The Palmer Centre would result in a review of the table money paid by members, and would probably result in an increase in table money. There was a suggestion from the floor, that prize money was abolished, and a show of hands following the suggestion resulted in a majority of members willing to abolish the table money. It was agreed that this suggestion would not be adopted at this stage, but the Committee would discuss the position at the next Committee meeting. JW then thanked Hugh Green for auditing the accounts for the Club and gave a brief overview of the figures, explaining about the depreciation of assets and confirming that the Clubs finances were in a healthy state. MS asked when the AGM would be moved to – JW responded that the AGM would be held within the normal timescale after the completion of the annual accounts. Marjorie Terrill proposed adoption of the accounts and Doreen Griffiths seconded
10. Appointment of Auditor – The Treasurer stated that Hugh Green had indicated that he was prepared to continue in the role. Sandra Gregory proposed and Alethea Tonner seconded that he should continue. This was overwhelmingly accepted.
11. Motions Received –
i) “A member shall be eligible to play in Club competitions provided that he/she has been a member for three months or longer” Proposer Peter Smith, Seconder Marion Shewell. PS explained that Clubs such as Newport and Bristol imposed this restriction to prevent new people joining their Club (whose ability was unknown to the Club) and then immediately entering competitions where there were large monetary prizes, and winning. The three month period gave the Clubs time to assess the players ability and impose handicaps as necessary. PS acknowledged that CABC was not holding competitions of that nature, and it would simply be putting the rule in place in case it was needed for the future. Brian Harden disagreed stating that is more important for the Club to be as flexible as possible to encourage new members to play. The motion was put to the vote and defeated there only being 9 members in favour.
ii) “that a vote be taken to decide whether or not to keep the dealing machine which is on sale of return”. Proposer Gail Jones, Seconder Helen Street. Gail firstly questioned whether the Committee had the authority of the members to purchase the Dealing Machine. PT referred back to the Minutes of the previous AGM and clarified that the Committee did have the authority to proceed with the purchase. Gail then went on to explain why she had proposed the motion, stating that she found the distribution of the hands very odd and that they were difficult to play, and that the Newport Bridge Club dealing machine did not deal such odd hands. Tony Waters also said that he found the hands awkward and not enjoyable to play. Richard Stevenson responded by stating that the deals were completely random and more distributional than hand dealt cards, which were generally very poorly dealt, and the hands coming out of the board was very similar when it had been dealt and put back in the board. Those dealt by the machine were random and that one would develop the ability to play these hands, with more practice, and this would lead to improved play and better competition. Graham Eele endorsed Richard’s comments on hands dealt by the machine saying that they were genuinely random – that you would get hands that would include extreme distribution , hands that got passed out and hands that were played at the one or two level. Greg Howell responded to Gail’s comments on the Newport dealing machine, explaining that they used exactly the same software and machine as the Club. Several members including BH and Pam Robinson(PR) expressed a preference for the Dealing Machine Hands, and PR suggested that if there was a demand there could be an occasional evening when they went back to hand dealing the cards. The motion was put to the vote 26 members voted in favour of keeping the machine and 7 against.
12. Any Other Business –
i) Greg and Richard said the Club would need to purchase another set of Boards if it was decided to have hand dealt cards as they needed to be kept separate from the Machine Dealt cards.
ii) PS requested that a copy of the Committee Meeting Minutes be placed on the Notice Board as well as the website and the agenda be circulated in advance of the meeting. JM agreed to discuss with committee.
13. AOB – BH thanked JM and JW for taking over their respective roles and stepping into the breach. JM also thanked Carolyne Ogden for all her work leading up to the AGM.
The meeting closed at 19.00hrs.
Top of Page
CHEPSTOW ARCHWAY CLUB RULES
1. The name of the club shall be “Chepstow Archway Bridge Club”.
2. The object of the club is to provide facilities for its members to play Bridge.
3.(a) The responsibility for the general day to day running of the club shall be vested in a
Committee consisting of the Chairman, Secretary, Treasurer and up to five  other
(b) The Committee shall be elected at the annual general meeting in each year and,
subject to termination of office by resignation or otherwise, shall remain in office until their
successors are elected at the annual general meeting next following their election.
(c) The Committee shall have power to fill any vacancy which may occur.
(d) The quorum at a meeting of the Committee shall be four.
(e) The retiring members of the Committee shall be eligible for re-election.
4. The Chairman shall take the chair at all meetings of the club. In the event of the
votes in any motion being equal the Chairman shall be entitled to give a casting vote in
addition to his vote as a member. In the absence of the Chairman, the meeting may, by
simple majority, elect a deputy.
5. The Secretary or acting Secretary shall carry out the directions of the Committee
and shall attend all meetings of the Committee and be responsible for the taking of
minutes of the proceedings.
6.(a) The Treasurer shall keep proper record of all monies received and expended on
behalf of the Club. They shall, when required to do so, render to the Committee or a
general meeting an account of any monies received or expended. Any two of four 
nominated Committee members shall sign all cheques or payments on behalf of the club.
(b) The Treasurer shall keep a list of the names, telephone and other contact details of
the members of the club in which shall also be recorded the payment of subscriptions by
such members. [in accordance with The Data Protection Act]
7.(a) The annual subscription for members shall be such sum as the Club shall, in its
annual general meeting, determine. It is a requirement of the club that any member is
also member of the Welsh Bridge Union. Any membership fee due to the Welsh Bridge
Union must be paid at the same time as the annual subscription. The amount of table
money shall be such as shall be decided by the Committee.
(b) Any person becoming a member of the Club at least six months after the
subscription becomes due in any year shall pay half the current subscription of the
Club, plus the sum required to fulfil Welsh Bridge membership.
14 of 19
(c) Any member who has not paid their subscription within one month after it has
become due shall be considered as “in arrears” and if it be not paid within one month
thereafter, they shall cease to be a member and their name shall, at the discretion of the
Committee, be erased from the list of members. Thereupon such member shall lose all the
privileges of membership.
(d) The committee shall have power to expel any member or social player who shall
offend against the rules of the Club or whose conduct shall, in the opinion of the
Committee, render them unfit for membership of the Club. Before any such member is
expelled, the Secretary shall give them seven days notice in writing to attend a meeting of
the Committee and shall inform them of the complaints made against him. No member
shall be expelled without first having an opportunity of appearing before the Committee
and answering the complaints made against them and unless at least two-thirds of the
Committee then present vote in favour of their expulsion. No member whose membership
has been terminated under this rule or who owes money to the Club shall be introduced by
any other member as a visitor to the Club.
8. A general meeting of the Club shall be held October or November every year on a
date to be fixed by the committee to transact the following business:-
(a) To receive and, if approved, to adopt a statement of the Club’s accounts to the
end of the preceding Club year.
(b) To consider and, if approved, to sanction any proposed change of the rules.
(c) To appoint officers and other members of the Committee
(d) To appoint auditors
(e) To deal with any special matter which the Committee desires to bring before the
members and to receive suggestions from the members for consideration by the
Committee. Notice convening the general meeting shall be sent to members not less than
twenty-one days before the AGM and shall specify the matters to be dealt with.
9. At least fourteen days before the date appointed for the annual general meeting
nominations for those prepared to carry out the duties of the officers and other members of
the Committee for the following twelve months shall be handed to one of the Committee.
Candidates for office shall be proposed and seconded by members who must personally
sign the sheet.
10. A special general meeting may be convened at any time by the Committee, and or
shall be convened within twenty-one days from the receipt of a requisition in writing signed
by five or more members. At least twenty-one days notice shall be given of any such
meeting specifying matters to be dealt with.
Such a meeting shall:-
(a) consider and, if approved, sanction any alterations of the rules;
(b) deal with any special matter which the Committee may desire to place before
(c) deal with any special matter which the members requisitioning the meeting may
desire to place before the Club.
15 of 19
11. Social Players ( who to be eligible must be paid-up 2015-2016 Club members) will
be required to pay no membership fee to the Club nor the Welsh or, and will have no
restriction placed on the number of visit they make in their lifetime on any normal club
night (subject to conduct) . They will be required to pay a more representative true cost in
attending any special event, as designated by the Club Committee. Social Players will
have no Club membership rights but a nominated person will be able to attend Committee
meetings of the Club as an observer. All Social Players may attend the Club’s Annual
General Meeting as observers.
12. No member or visitor shall be under the age of sixteen.
13. The Committee shall have the power to make bye-laws for regulating the conduct
and affairs of the club, provided the same are not inconsistent with the rules.
DRAFT 1 REVISIONS AGREED BY COMMITTEE FOR APPROVAL BY AGM 2017
Top of Page
BYE-LAWS FOR THE CONDUCT AND AFFAIRS OF THE CLUB
1. Any member attending the Christmas party (or any other event determined
by the Committee and attracting a subsidy), will only benefit from that
should they have played at the Club at least 12 times in the past year on
normal Club nights, unless it is agreed by the Chairman that special
dispensation should be awarded.
2. Members take precedence over social players in any club event where
places are limited
3. No annual Club subscription (including WBU membership) will be sought
from any member, who has had continuous membership for at least 10
years, in any year following their 90th birthday.
4. Visitors to the Club will be able to play on three separate occasions, within
one calendar year, before being required to become full members of the
5. Any member whose membership has lapsed will be unable to play as a
visitor at the Club for 12 months from the date of their membership ending.
6. The committee shall have power to expel any social player who shall offend
against the rules of the Club or whose conduct shall, in the opinion of the
Committee, render them unfit to play at the Club. Before a social player is
expelled the Secretary, shall give them seven days notice in writing to
attend a meeting of the committee and shall inform them of the complaints
made against them. No social player shall be expelled without first having
an opportunity of appearing before the Committee and answering the
complaints made against them, and unless at least two-thirds of the
Committee then present vote in favour of their expulsion. Any social player
sanctioned in this way forfeits any future right to play at the Club as a
7. Social Players (who were eligible having been paid-up 2015-2016 Club
members) will be required to pay no membership fee to the Club, nor the
Welsh Bridge Union and will have no restriction placed on the number of
visits they make in their lifetime on any normal club night (subject to
conduct). They will be required to pay a more representative true cost in
attending any special event, as designated by the Club Committee.
8. Social Players may nominate one representative, whose name has been
registered with the Club Secretary, who may attend Committee Meetings
and the AGM as an observer.
9. Social Players and visitors will pay table money of £1 more than that paid
by members of the Club.
Top of Page
THURSDAY 7 CHRISTMAS PARTY
MONDAY 25 CLOSED CHRISTMAS AND NEW YEAR
MONDAY 1 CLOSED – NEW YEAR’S DAY
MONDAY 8 COMMITTEE MEETING
THURSDAY 8 ECATS CHARITY CHALLENGE SIMS PAIRS IN AID OF THE RNLI
MONDAY 12 COMMITTEE MEETING
THURSDAY 29 EASTER EGG EVENT
FRIDAY 30 CLOSED – GOOD FRIDAY
MONDAY 2 CLOSED – EASTER MONDAY
MONDAY 7 CLOSED – MAY BANK HOLIDAY
MONDAY 14 COMMITTEE MEETING
MONDAY 28 CLOSED – SPRING BANK HOLIDAY
THURSDAY 31 CLUB CHARITY EVENT
MONDAY 9 COMMITTEE MEETING
THURSDAY 19 SUMMER PARTY
MONDAY 27 CLOSED AUGUST BANK HOLIDAY
MONDAY 10 COMMITTEE MEETING
MONDAY 24 CLARET CUP
MONDAY 29 AGM
MONDAY 12 ECATS CHARITY CHALLENGE SIMS PAIRS IN AID OF CHILDREN IN NEED
MONDAY 12 COMMITTEE MEETING
THURSDAY 6 CHRISTMAS PARTY
MONDAY 24 CLOSED CHRISTMAS AND NEW YEAR
WEDNESDAY 2 CLUB OPENS FOR 2019
Top of Page
CHEPSTOW ARCHWAY BRIDGE CLUB
MINUTES OF AGM 7th NOVEMBER 2016
A sheet circulated during the meeting for those present to record their attendance showed that there were forty-nine members and two potential members present.
1) Apologies for Absence – Thirteen apologies had been received by the secretary before the meeting and a further three were received at the meeting.
2) Minutes of AGM 29th October 2015 – Christine Brierley proposed and Steve Dobney seconded the adoption of the minutes as recorded. Their adoption was accepted overwhelmingly.
3) Matters Arising – There were no matters arising that were not already on the agenda.
4) Chairman’s report – The chairman gave a comprehensive report. He began by saying that this year has been very eventful, particularly with the WBU notification that from 2017 onwards all members of a WBU affiliated club must themselves be individual members of the WBU and that the Committee was unanimously in favour of continuing the Club affiliation to the WBU but also recognised that mandatory affiliation for all Club members was a very contentious and divisive issue. In the event a Special General Meeting (SGM) was convened to decide the issue with all Club members being eligible to vote even if unable to attend the meeting. At that SGM the majority of the Club membership voted to continue the WBU affiliation. Existing Club members who do not wish to affiliate to the WBU as individuals can continue to play bridge as currently as social bridge players. The issue is not yet fully resolved as there is a further motion for the formation of a Wednesdays only club to be considered later in the agenda.
He continued by mentioning the sad loss of Jack Hunter and the charity event held for the benefit of The Salvation Army, Jack’s favourite charity, and went on to mention the events held for Children In Need and the McMillan Nurses and that the club had donated a total of £740 to the charities this year. He reminded members that this year’s charity event in favour of Children In Need was to be held in a week’s time with a ticket price of £4.
Other points mentioned in his report were the teams entered in the East Wales Bridge League and matches against Monmouth and the U3A, the seminars held by Peter Smith and Graham Eele, the Christmas, Easter and 40th anniversary parties and the Claret Cup competition won by Christine Brierley and Peter Cole. He also mentioned the trial of prepared hands to help members form an opinion on the purchase of a dealing machine, an agenda item later in the meeting. He further mentioned the handicapped results that appeared on the website and the committee’s intention to introduce periodic prizes for the most improved handicaps, and that prize money on club evenings would continue to be awarded on unhandicapped results.
The Chairman also stated that membership remains strong with the treasurer recording over ninety paid up members although not all were active. He anticipated a change to this situation with some members opting to become social players and encouraged members to encourage new members.
Looking to the future he pointed out that it had been a difficult year for the club with the divisions over the issue of WBU affiliation but stated that the Special General Meeting gave a way ahead and referred to the motion for a separate Wednesday club to be considered later in the agenda.
Finally he mentioned that Peter Smith was stepping down from the position of secretary after seven years of sterling service and thanked him on behalf of all the members for his efforts. He went on to say that he had been chairman for three years and felt that the Chairman’s role in particular does need to be refreshed periodically in the best interests of the Club. He said that he would continue as Chairman for a further and final year if the membership wished it.
The chairman concluded by thanking the membership generally for the support that they had given to the committee over the year with a particular thank you to those who arrive early and help set up or who stay later to help shut down.
5) Treasurer’s report – In the unavoidable absence of the treasurer the chairman thanked her and Hugh Green for their work including preparing and auditing the accounts. He went on to refer to the accounts and drew attention to the main points as follows (with figures for the preceeding year in brackets):
• Income from table money less prize monies slightly down at £4560 (£4662)
• Annual Subs income £534 for current membership of 92 (£555)
• Other income includes £250 from Newnham Bridge Club for old Bridgemates and laptop
• Nett interest of £11
Total Income of £6167
• Main expenditure was rent at £3475 (£3450)
• Charitable donations were £740 (£770)
• Christmas party Nett costs of £471 (£607)
• Summer Party actually made a small profit of £39 because of catering efficiencies
• Depreciation on Scoring equipments of £567 (£0)
• Miscellaneous expenses were £354 with lots of detail available on the supporting sheet (£130)
Total Expenditure for the year £6003
Yielding a surplus of income over expenditure for the year of £164 (£600)
Adding the surplus carried forward from last of £7044 yields:
Surplus carried forward to next year of £7208 comprising:
• Cash £5145
• Stocks of cards & wine £361
• Computer Equipment value at £1702
6) Adoption of accounts for 2015-2016 – A number of questions were asked as follows (with answers from the chairman):
Q From Colin Stocks – Do club rules require a minimum balance to be held at the bank? A No
Q From Steve Dobney – The club rules state that subscriptions are to be decided at the AGM. Was there to be a vote tonight and would they be raised? A No. The CABC membership fee remained at £6 with WBU fees paid through the CABC but kept separate, so no vote was necessary.
Q From Ray Mardon (prospective member) – Would there be any charges for social players? A No
Q From Brian Harden – Does the prize money depend on the level of rent and would it need to go down if the rent went up if that were the case? A prize money is decided on by the committee who bear in mind several things when deciding it, including reserves. No rent increases have been proposed to the club at present.
Q From Eve Walters – Are Wednesday evening club nights different to the others? A Only as far that Bridgemates are not used for scoring. It is not envisaged that any changes will occur under the new WBU affiliation requirements.
Grace Martyn then proposed and Marion Jones seconded the adoption of the accounts. They were adopted overwhelmingly.
7) Appointment of auditor – The Chairman stated that Hugh Green had indicated that he was prepared to continue in that role. Marjorie Evans proposed and Chris Ballard seconded that he be should continue. This was accepted overwhelmingly.
8) Appointment of officers and Committee members: Apart from Peter Smith who was retiring as secretary all the other officers, namely the present chairman Peter Taylor, the present treasurer – Marion Shewell and all other committee members Sue Blake, Graham Eele, John Mayo, John Whiteside, Ian Wood indicated their willingness to continue. Grace Martyn has agreed to be nominated as Committee member, replacing Carolyne Ogden who is the only nominee for Secretary. In a response to the chairman’s request for a proposer and seconder for a motion to elect those willing to continue, Carolyne as secretary and Grace as a replacement for Carolyne several members put themselves forward. The following vote was accepted overwhelmingly.
9) Motions received:
a) Wednesday Club run separately as a non-affiliated club – Proposed and seconded by Reg and Jean Edwards. Jean was invited by the chairman to speak in support of her motion. She said that Wednesday evenings was different from other club evenings and had originally been started following the demise of the Hospital Club (which had transferred funds of about £600 to CABC) and that when she joined CABC there was no mention of joining the WBU. She felt that it was only a relatively small group of members that were taking the club into the WBU and that a vote for by all members at a different stage would have given a different result. She said that the EBU operated with a mixed membership of affiliated and non affiliated members. She proposed that the Wednesday evenings should be run separately as a non-affiliated club. Jean concluded her remarks by saying that she didn’t want to be dictated to and wouldn’t accept charity so after thirty years she and Reg were not prepared to be second class members so , with regret, they resigned, finally stating that they will miss the company of the friends that they had made and wished them well for the future.
A number of statements and questions followed from the floor.
Greg Howell – There was no reason why a separate non affiliated club could not be formed.
Chairman – The club had been affiliated to the WBU for ten years.
Eve Walters – Could membership of a separate Wednesday club be ‘covered’ by CABC? – The chairman replied that a club within a club was not feasible.
Marjorie Evans – said that she was not at the SGM and needed some clarification. In response Greg Howell explained that a new Wednesday club would be completely separate from CABC.
Jenny Heathorne – Queried if rent of the centre would be different if the club changed – The chairman replied that it may be but would be subject to negotiation with the Palmer Centre for any new club.
Jean Edwards – stated that the rent was lowered when Wednesday evening club nights started – The chairman acknowledged that but pointed out that it was over twenty years ago. He added that the Palmer centre might not even be a viable proposition without CABC.
Margaret Bennett – asked about the position with insurances if a separate Wednesday club was formed – The chairman said that it would have to be separate from CABC
Marion Jones – said that she felt that we would be better together as one club.
Bridget Evans – said that although she played mostly on Mondays and Thursdays she occasional played on Wednesdays and didn’t regard those evenings as separate, but different and would be sad if they were to go.
Chairman – said that the overriding objective of the committee was to avoid a split in the club.
Colin Stocks – asked what the WBU membership was, the chairman replied £10 and added that Peter Smith had vigorously argued against the new WBU rule.
Gail Jones – pointed out that social players would have no say in the running of the club but the chairman pointed out that the proposal put to the SGM included that a representative of the social players should attend committee meetings. He added that the proposal for a dealing machine was being voted on later so that all current members could vote.
Marjorie Terrell – understood that previously the treasurer had said that Wednesday evenings operated at a loss, the chairman said that that had been previously recorded in minutes but all nights were now generally OK financially.
A vote was then taken. Three were in favour of the motion, the majority against.
A few other comments followed from the floor with Bridget Evans finally thanking Reg and Jean Edwards for all that they had done for the club. They were then applauded by the members and Jean thanked those present for the response.
b) The Committee be authorised to investigate and then purchase a dealing machine to allow the use of prepared hands at the discretion of the Director of an evening’s play-Proposed by Richard Stevenson, seconded by Stewart Anderton.
Richard was invited by the chairman to speak in support of his motion. He made a number of points including:
It was discussed at last year’s AGM
We had trialled prepared hands
Benefits included fewer ‘flat’ hands and improved games
Members would be better prepared for competitions if a machine were used
Other clubs feedback in favour was very positive
The potential cost to the club over five years would be about 25p per player each night
The vote was appropriate tonight as we had trialled prepared hands an all members had had long notice and could vote.
A number of statements and questions followed from the floor.
Nick Jones – asked if we have the expertise to use a machine, Richard (RS) replied that it was not burdensome.
Nick Jones – asked if it would be time consuming, Greg Howell responded that it should take about twenty minutes to do twenty eight boards.
Peter Cole – said that each member should decide on the benefits that they would receive and that there would be no point in voting for something that 90% of members would ignore.
Marion Jones – asked if a team would be required to use it, Greg replied that it would be similar to the way the computer was operated.
Christine Brierley – Thought that most members ‘wouldn’t want to know anything about it’, the chairman thought that even if you don’t use the available information yourself you might accept that it benefitted others.
Liz Klinkert – asked if a machine would help in rectifying misboarded hands, RS replied that it would in some instances.
Sandra Gregory – asked if special cards were required and was the cost included in the stated price. Greg replied that special cards were required but that most that were in stock were already suitable and that new ones would be no more expensive than ordinary ones.
Colin Stocks – pointed out that the anticipated cost was about £2,500 and that we have about £5,000 in reserve. He also pointed out that the motion did not include a ceiling price and that the members were therefore being asked to approve a potentially unlimited expenditure.
Marion Jones – asked where it was proposed to store it, Greg responded in our cupboards. He added on a separate note that it could be used to print the information on hands dealt for players to take away after the evening’s play.
A vote was then taken and (including votes sent to the secretary and chairman prior to the meeting) the result was twenty-eight in favour, seventeen against with seven abstentions.
Subsequently a short discussion took place on finances after members queried the possibility of spending more than the figures referred to. Greg Howell said that he and Richard Stevenson were prepared to subsidise the cost. John Mayo said that in a personal capacity he would be reluctant to agree to any substantial ‘overspend’ without discussing it with members and would give that view at committee meetings if the problem arose.
10) Any Other Business Marjorie Terrell spoke about the condition of the cloths for the tables and the boards and several present supported her views. The chairman responded that new boards were already being considered but the committee would also consider cloths as a priority.
Marion Jones thanked the chairman and committee for their efforts and applause was given.
Brian Harden asked who would now organise Wednesday evenings and was told by the chairman that Sue Blake had offered to do so for the time being.
The meeting was closed at 7.30.
Top of Page
Chicago Charity Bridge Drive 2017
The Charity Bridge Drive was held on 11th September in memory of George Smith, a very long serving member of the Club, who died earlier in the year.
Funds were raised on behalf of St David’s Hospice who had cared for George and supported his wife Val and their family during his final illness.
The event raised £500 for St David’s through the sales of tickets and a raffle.
Many thanks to all those who attended the event or who donated food or raffle prizes, which ensured that the evening was very enjoyable and a great success.
Top of Page
Draft Minutes of Committee Meeting Monday 8th January 2018
PRESENT : John Mayo, John Whiteside, Carolyne Ogden, Graham Eele, Grace Martyn, Sue Blake, Alethea Tonner
APOLOGIES: Sheila Montgomery,
1. The Minutes of the Committee Meeting held on Monday 6th November were accepted as a true record by those in attendance at the meeting.
2. Treasurers Report
a. The total cost of the Christmas party to the Club was £596. It was agreed that for the next Christmas party the member’s contribution would need to be raised (to at least £10 dependent on the caterer’s charges).
b. Attendance numbers are down, with some night’s table monies barely covering the rent of the room, if at all. In an attempt to forestall a potential increase in table money it was agreed that the prize money, in its current form, paid at the end of the evening, should be abolished. This was in line with the vote that took place at the AGM. (item 9 “There was a suggestion from the floor, that prize money was abolished, and a show of hands following the suggestion resulted in a majority of members willing to abolish the table money.”) This will come into effect at the end of January. In its place the Committee members are working to implement a new periodic set of prizes. (JM to lead discussion with Committee on the format and frequency of these prizes, by email and agree implementation with JW and GE). This will be communicated to the club by email, and will be placed on the noticeboard, and an announcement will be made by each evening’s director, at the end of January If the Palmer Centre does increase the rent this will necessarily result in a need to review the table money.
c. Membership – the subscriptions are continuing to come in and JW should have the final numbers (with a few exceptions) by the end of the month. JW will then produce a new membership list.
d. GE raised the issue of changes in the General Data Protection Regulation, which will come into force in May 2018 as a result of EU legislation (and will most likely be enshrined in UK legislation following Brexit.). JW and CO had already been in discussion about this as we need to have our members’ express permission to communicate with them in future. JW will communicate with WBU to find out what they are advising/proposing to do and what we as a club are obliged to do.
3. Catering – SB spoke about comments she had received about the Christmas party which were discussed by the Committee. AT has taken over the organisation of catering and will be reviewing the catering for the Christmas party on 6/12/18 and reporting back to the Committee.
4. Beginners Bridge Course – GE reported that five people had signed up so far, (GM asked for details of the course for a member of her family who wished to sign up). Posters have been put up at local venues, other groups had been informed and details were placed on U3A website. More people will need to sign up to make the course viable. It was agreed that if there is a small shortfall in the required break-even number then the Club would subsidise the Course. It is possible that if GE follows the WBU training course that they will reduce the WBU annual fee by £5 for each trainee, and the Committee were in favour of this proposal. GE said that there will also need to be support from the Committee, to assist in the running of the course and he will let the Committee know how many and what is required nearer the time.
5. GE suggested that generally we should advertise the club more and suggested various publications to target. He suggested that someone should take responsibility for this role, and following discussion may know someone willing to do this for the Club. He will report back at the next meeting.
6. Bridge Evenings – It was confirmed that JW will direct on a Monday evening with PT on the computer. SB will direct on a Wednesday evening with GE on the computer (this is our weakest evening in terms of back-up for both directing and operating the computer). JM will direct on Thursday evening with GM on computer. In addition to this Brian Harden, Greg Howell, Sheila Montgomery and Stewart Anderton are very willing to help out. JM will sound out members of the club to see if there are any other people who would be interested in supporting the running of Club evenings and arranging for anyone who would like to learn to operate the Bridgemates. JM will be issuing another rota for the dealing machine before the end of the month.
7. ECATS Charity Challenge Sims – March 8th – GE is happy to liaise with ECATS in acquiring the files and setting up. A poster for the event is on the Notice Board and Directors will announce the event on Club nights nearer the time.
8. Masterpoints – carried forward SM.
9. Boards – the playing cards in some of the boards are becoming very grubby. The Director for each evening to make a note of boards where cards need to be changed. There are plenty of packs in the computer cupboard so change the relevent boards at the end of the evening .
a. JM will speak to Greg and thank him for his offer (at the AGM) to purchase another set of Boards for the club, but decline, as we do not need them at this time.
b. Summer Charity Event – this year the Charity Event will be held on Thursday 31 May. Committee to consider which Charity should be supported and possibly sound out members views
c. 90+ SB to speak to MS regarding qualifying candidates (bye-laws No.3)
d. Palmer Centre AGM – SB will raise the issue of the heating being left on longer in the evenings as the temperature in the hall drops very rapidly and members have been complaining about the chill.
The next meeting will be on Monday 12th March at 18.00hrs.
Top of Page
Minutes of Committee Meeting Monday 6th November 2017
PRESENT : John Mayo, John Whiteside, Graham Eele, Grace Martyn, Sue Blake,
Sheila Montgomery, Alethea Tonner
APOLOGIES : Carolyne Ogden
1. The Minutes of the Committee Meeting held on Monday 2nd October were accepted as a true record by those in attendance at the meeting.
2. JM welcomed Sheila and Alethea and thanked them for agreeing to join the Committee.
3. The AGM ws reviewed at length. As a consequence of the discussions it was agreed that :
i) In future proxy votes would be introduced at the AGM
ii) The Claret Cup competition would be held on a separate evening to the AGM (format to be discussed in New Year).
iii) The £1 differential for social players would remain in place but their attendance would be monitored pending further discussion
iv) The number of evenings that a visitor could play at the Club would increased to six visits. The Treasurer should have the discretion to vary that number should circumstances merit it.
4. Master points would be discussed at the next meeting. SM will contact the WBU for information.
5. Treasurers Report – JW reported that the Barclays Bank account is now up and running The result of the Claret Cup competition was sent to the EWBU who have donated £30 to the winners. Subscriptions are now being received.
6. GE was happy the The Children In Need Event organsation was in hand.
7. The Christmas Party was only discussed briefly due to lack of time.
8. GE gave an outline of a training programme, and it was agreed that he should proceed with this in January. He was authorised by the Committee to act as he saw fit as there was insufficient time to discuss it at the meeting. SM expressed a particular interest in this area and has offered to become involved.
9. Nothing was discussed under AOB due to lack of time.
The next meeting will be on Monday 8th January 2018 at 18.00hrs
Top of Page
Minutes of Committee Meeting Monday October 2nd 2017
PRESENT : John Mayo, John Whiteside, Carolyne Ogden, Graham Eele, Grace Martyn, Ian Wood, Sue Blake
1. The Minutes of the Comittee Meetings held on Monday 14th August and Saturday 9th
September were unanimously accepted as a true record by those in attendance at the
2. Treasurers Report – JW reported on the handover of the accounts from MS and presented a
copy of the accounts for the year ended 30th September. JW gave a summary of the current
financial sitution and update on the the position of the Club’s bank accounts. JW will speak to
Hugh Green(HG) regarding the year end accounts and whether he is happy to carry on as
auditor going forward. There was a short discussion on the rate at which assets should be
depreciated, and it was thought that this was 25%, but JW will confirm with HG. Following the
Charity Event in September £500 was donated to St David’s Hospice.
3. The updated Bye-Laws for the Conduct and Affairs of the Club were discussed prior to
presentation at the AGM. An increase in the table money for social players was again
discussed and a proposal put forward by Pete Smith (PS) for the AGM, that the table money for
social players/visitors should be £1 more than that of members was discussed by the
Committee and it was agreed that this was an appropriate way forward. The increase will come
into effect on 1st November. (This does not take into account any increase in the rental of The
Palmer Centre – should this result in the need to increase the table money for members, the
social players/visitor table money will increase accordingly) There will be a notice placed on
the Notice Board, and JM will announce the change at the forthcoming bridge evenings. JM
will also speak to PS to ask whether he still wishes his proposal to be put forward.
4. The updated Bye-Laws will be amended and placed on the website in due time for the AGM,
there will be paper copies available on the evening.
5. AGM – the Agenda and accompanying documents have been emailed to all members for whom
we have an email address, and paper copies have been given to those members who do not
have email accounts. CO will email Proposal Forms to those members who have expressed
the intention to put forward a Motion to the AGM. These will need to be fully completed, with
details of the proposal, and the signatures of the Proposer and Seconder and the original form
to be returned to CO. Two members have put their names forward to join the Committee and
CO has the completed and signed nomination forms. JM will ask at the Bridge evenings
whether anyone else wishes to put their name forward for consideration at the AGM.
6. Children in Need Charity Evening – Monday 13th November. GE will liaise with PT to ensure
the smooth running of the evening. The table money for the event will be £5. A poster will go
on the board later this week. SB raised a concern about social players participating in the
evening as all the results are published. It was agreed that certainly for this year, as it was a
charity event that social players could participate.
7. Claret Cup – JM has undertaken to retrieve the Cup from Christine and Peter.
8. It was confirmed that annual subs are not due until the end of the year, but if members wish to
pay anytime onwards from the AGM the Treasurer will receive them.
9. Christmas Party – Preliminary details were outlined, but will be confirmed at the next meeting.
It was proposed that qualifying members would pay £6 and non-qualifying members and social
players would pay £20
10. Training – carried forward to next meeting
– SB asked whether the Committee were happy to pay the fees for the Club’s 2 teams in the
league. The Committee were unanimously in favour.
– The Committee unanimously agreed to cover the travel costs of the weekend Director Training
Course in Porthcawl for JM and JW at a rate of 20 pence per mile which should be adopted as
the current mileage rate. SB requested a copy of the Rule Book, which was also agreed.
12. The next meeting will be on Monday 6th November at 18.00hrs.
Top of Page
Minutes of Committee Meeting held on 9th September 2017
PRESENT : John Mayo, John Whiteside, Carolyne Ogden, Graham Eele Grace Martyn, Ian Wood,
APOLOGIES : Sue Blake
1. The Committee accepted the resignations of Peter Taylor and Marion Shewell and will write to
them both to thank them for their long and diligent service to the Club.
2. Endorsement of John Mayo and Chairman and John Whiteside as Treasurer. In accordance
with the Club rules (3a) “The Committee shall have power to fill any vacancy which may occur”.
The Committee unanimously agreed to endorse both John Mayo and John Whiteside in their
respective roles as Chairman and Treasurer. (SB sent an email confirming her endorsement)
3. The paperwork for the SGM and AGM Minutes were discussed, and it was agreed that they
are ready for the AGM.
4. The Notice of the AGM will be published within the next 14 days to give the members time to
submit any Motions to be considered by the AGM
5. One candidate has come forward to stand for the Committee, and a nomination form will be
6. A notice should be prepared to invite members to put themselves forward to join the
Committee, and Committee Members will also canvas the members to find candidates.
7. Ian Wood stated that due to lack of time to devote to the role, he was not offering himself for reelection.
8. JW reported on the handover of the Treasurers role from Marion. JW is investigating changing
from a building society to a bank for the Club’s finances as this may be more convenient. John
Whiteside, Carolyne Ogden, Graham Eele and Grace Martyn to become signatories for the
club’s account, depending on the requirements of the bank.
9. JW has spoken to Hugh Green who has confirmed that he is happy to continue as the club’s
10. JW will also review the costs of running a Bridge Session to enable a a more representative
table money charge, this will also include the outcome of the rent review by The Palmer
11. JW has the authority of the Committee to make any payments on behalf of CABC.
12. Claret Cup – a notice will go on the board stating that the competition will not start until 19.30.
This will allow enough time for the AGM and ensure that Social Players are not waiting outside
the hall, or interrupting the AGM.
13. Arrangements will need to be made to regain the Claret Cup from Christine and Peter, and JW
will need to arrange the prize money for the highest ranking members. We shall need to have
some wine on hand in case a Social Player pair win.
14. A notice, agreed by the Committee, will be sent to Social Players, to ask if they wish to
nominate one of their number to be their representative observer at the AGM.
15. Graham Eele will check with Peter Taylor the format for the Children in Need event, and will
direct the evening if needed..
16. Arrangements are in hand for the Charity Event on Monday 11th September, there will be 13
17. Chepstow -v- Monmouth match, the teams members have all confirmed their availability. JM
will direct . The refreshments will be wine and cheese.
18. Grace raised the matter of confidentiality of discussions in Committee. It was agreed that all
matters discussed in committee were confidential and should not be discussed with anyone
other than committee members. No Committee member should seek advice on committee
matters from anyone outside the Committee, without Committee approval.
19. The Committee Meeting scheduled for Monday 18th September has been cancelled and will
now take place on Monday 2nd October.
Top of Page
Minutes of Committee Meeting Monday 14TH August 2017
PRESENT : Peter Taylor (Chairman), Carolyne Ogden, John Mayo,Graham Eele , Sue Blake, Ian Wood, John Whiteside
APOLOGIES : Grace Martyn, Marion Shewell
1. The Minutes of the Committee Meeting held on Monday 15th May 2017 were accepted as a
true record. ( A question was raised regarding point 9 – the future maintenance of the Club’s
website – Peter Taylor has confirmed that he will to continue to manage the site, but that the
situation will need to be reviewed in the long term. He confirmed that he will be visiting Bristol
Bridge Club to see how the Pianola System they are using works and will report back to the
2. Brian Harden’s letter – the contents were discussed in great detail and all the attendees, agreed
in principle to Peter’s proposed response. Carolyne will draft the letter and forward to the
Committee for their comments. A final version will be circulated, prior to posting to Brian, at the
end of this week.
3. Review of Marion and Sue’s Paper on the Club Bye-Laws :
i. Table Money – a decision on this has been deferred until The Palmer Centre have
implemented their proposed rental increase. Once the details have been received,
this subject will be added to the Agenda of the next Committee Meeting.
ii. Social Events Attendance – Agreed
iii. AGM Attendance – this was discussed at great length, and consensus could not be
reached. It was finally agreed that the Social Players could nominate one
representative to attend the AGM as an observer.
iv. Attendance requirements – consensus could not be reached in the short time
available, so this point can be reviewed again at the Committee Meeting to decide
the Table Money in the New Year.
4. Constitutional proposal to be carried forward (as i. and iv. above)
5. Training – discussion was curtailed due to lack of time, but, Graham has undertaken to speak to
Pete Smith. A suggestion was made to speak to Brian, who has in the past undertaken training
courses. A letter from the WBU Education and Club Liaison Officer had been received, but
there had not been time to discuss the contents. A copy of the letter is appended to the
Minutes, and the Committee is requested to send their views to the Secretary to enable a
response to be sent to Julie Davis.
6. Chepstow-v- Monmouth Match will take place on Wednesday 13th September – no time to
discuss. Committee will be emailed on progress
7. Charity Event – Monday 11th September, Members are signing up and Committee will be
informed of progress, Ticket sales have started well.
8. The Next Meeting will be on Monday 18th September at 17.30hrs
Top of Page
Minutes of Committee Meeting Monday 15th MAY 2017
Present : Peter Taylor (Chairman), Carolyne Ogden, Marion Shewell, John Mayo, Graham Eele , Sue Blake, Grace Martyn, Ian Wood
Apologies : John Whiteside
1. The Minutes of the Committee Meeting held on Monday 20th March 2017 were accepted as a true record.
2. The Treasurer reported that all outgoings had been paid, and that there was £2,706 in the Clubs account.
3. The email request regarding discontinuing the use of the dealing machine on Wednesday evenings was considered and the Committee unanimously agreed that following an informal assessment of the views of members who have regularly attended Wednesday meetings in 2017 that a change in the format of the evening was not appropriate as it was felt there was sufficient support for the dealing machine and a reluctance on the part of the committee to have a different format on Wednesday evenings. Pete will prepare a draft response to the email input and circulate to the rest of the committee before issuing.
4. Following discussion on training requirements, it was agreed that this year there would be no external training course offered. Graham will, however, liaise with Pete S and consider the preparation of a course of 2 – 3 sessions, to take place before start of play on a Wednesday evening to review and discuss how particular boards played on the previous Wednesday should be played to achieve the best results.
5. Social Players – there had been no representative nominated by the players. Following a brief discussion on their status it was agreed to carry it forward to next meeting.
6. The format for the Summer Party was agreed. Carolyne will cater the event, and it would be a “Teams Event”. As this required even numbers of pairs to make up the tables, members will have priority, if there are spare places available social players may attend at a cost of £5 per head.
7. It was agreed that the Constitution, as endorsed at the SGM and subsequently published on the website did not require any further amendment.
8. The Club Bye-laws were discussed; Marion and Sue will email the Committee with their suggested additions/amendments for discussion and endorsement by the Committee at the next meeting.
9. The future maintenance of the Club’s website following the AGM, when Peter will stand down, was discussed. Graham and Ian will work with Peter to become familiar with the management of the site.
10. The next meeting will be Monday 14th August at 18.00
Top of Page
Committee meeting minutes 20th MARCH 2017
Present: Peter Taylor (Chairman), Marion Shewell, John Mayo, Sue Blake, John Whiteside, Ian Wood, Grace Martyn
1) Apologies had been received from Carolyne Ogden and Graham Eele.
2) The minutes of 16th January were accepted as a true record.
3) Marion reported that we had £3227 in our account but further fees of approximately £400 will soon need to be paid to the WBU and a £56 payment for the teams of eight would reduce the balance further. No further significant payments are anticipated at present. The balance is lower than it has been for a while because of the major outlay for the dealing machine.
4) Ian reported that we currently have 67 members paying WBU fees through the club and 3 paying by other means. There are currently 22 social players. WBU payment status for two members is uncertain but being clarified.
5) Various aspects of the constitution (rules) and bye-laws were discussed. It was agreed that the reference to ‘home country’ in the Constitution should be deleted as we now know that all members of an affiliated WBU club must pay WBU subs (It was originally thought the membership to the EBU was sufficient) and it was agreed that the club should pay all fees for members over ninety years of age. The Chairman stated that he was wondering if we really need further changes to the constitution (rules) and bye-laws that had been recently amended to reflect decisions made at last Augusts’ SGM. After much discussion, especially about the status of social players, it was decided that all committee members would reconsider current documents and recent proposals before the next committee meeting when further discussions would take place.
6) The Chairman summarised the position concerning the progress with the use of the dealing machine. He acknowledged the generous contribution of Greg and Richard who had provided extra boards to enable full sets to be dealt once a week (with one set in reserve). John Mayo will organise the rota for using the machine each week.
7) As Graham was absent the report on training will be carried over till the next meeting.
8) Peter had attended the Palmer Centre trustees meeting as Sue could not attend. He reported that the lease to the trustees from the Council only had a short time to run and the Council’s intentions regarding the future of the centre are uncertain. The trustees are in a strong financial position and the CABC is a major user of the centre.
9) The Monmouth club had cancelled their match with us. No revised date has been set. Arrangements for the Easter egg competition are in hand. Peter Taylor will ‘run’ it and Helen and Gail will provide catering in Carolyne’s absence.
10) It was agreed that the beneficiary for the September charity event would be chosen by Val Smith (possibly the St. David’s Foundation) in memory of George. It was agreed that funds to be donated would be given straight to the charity rather than via sponsorship to raise further funds so that both the source of the donation and the fact that it was in memory of George would be clear to the recipient.
11) After much discussion about the status of social players it was decided to leave things as they are at present but to discuss their position in relation to such things as the Claret Cup competition at the next meeting.
12) The recent revision of the insurance cover to reflect the additional assets of the club and the associated increased premium was discussed and endorsed by all present.
13) Sue has brought the audit of the club’s assets up to date. Peter has marked our major belongings with an indelible marker.
14) Under any other business Marion raised the question of general responsibility for catering. This rests with Carolyne at present but it was agreed that, as she already has heavy responsibilities, she should be approached to clarify if she was happy with the current situation or would like to reduce her commitments.
15) Date and time of next meeting will be Monday 15th May 2017 at 6.00
Top of Page
At the last 2 Club AGMs some interest has been expressed in scoring Club evenings using individual handicaps.
The ScoreBridge system does allow the creation of historic handicap files which can then be applied to the raw scores generated for the evening. These handicap files can be created using any number of selected previously scored events and can be applied on either an individual or a pair basis. The handicap is normally for an individual, and the average of two individuals’ handicaps is applied to a Pairs result. If an individual does not have a handicap, his / hers is taken as zero. An average of 52% in previously scored games gives a handicap of 2%. Different weightings can be applied to the handicaps.
If Player A has an average score of 52% in previous events and Player B 54% their combined handicap when they play together would be 3%. With a weighting of 1 that pair would have 3% deducted from their score when the rankings for the evening are generated.
A handicaps file has been created using all the results scored with new scoring system in 2015.
On occasion results generated using the handicaps will be displayed on the Club website after the results generated without using handicaps.
For the time being at least prize money will continue to be awarded on the results generated WITHOUT using the handicaps.
Top of Page
MINUTES of a SPECIAL GENERAL MEETING 22nd AUGUST 2016
Forty six members attended. Peter Taylor, Peter Smith , Sue Blake, Carolyne Ogden, Marion Shewell, Graham Eele, John Whiteside, John Mayo, Liz Klinkert, Gail Jones, Peter Cole, Christine Brierley, Tony Vickers, Rosemary Allen, Marjorie Tyrell, Patricia Davies, Doreen Griffiths, Glad Williams, Jenny Vickers, Jean Edwards, Steve Dobney, Helen Street, Brian Harden, Marilyn Bond, Mary Shapland, Eve Walters, Rosemary Seymour-Williams, Viola Stephens, Daphne Bird, Peter Baumgardt, Elaine Gardener, Stuart Anderton, Chris Ballard, Eddie Belcher, Sandra Gregory, Kath Fallon, Margaret Anstey, Grace Martyn, John Martyn, Brandon Waters, Pat Waters, Bridget Evans, Bill Champion, Sue Burrows, Barbara Lenthell, Ian Wood.
Twelve members were unable to attend and sent apologies. Tony Waters, Sheila Bateman, Marina Hunter, Nick Jones, Marion Jones, Greg Howell, Richard Stevenson, Angela King, Mary Kennedy, Hugh Green, Morris Arthur, Liz Thompson.
Peter Taylor (PT), the club’s Chairman, welcomed those present at the meeting which had been called to determine how the club would deal with the WBU’s requirement that in future all members of affiliated clubs should be members of the WBU and pay the annual subscription. He stated that the club’s rules made provision for calling a special general meeting and that the committee had called the meeting as the issue was clearly divisive and needed to be addressed urgently. Because of the importance of the decision required allied to the fact that the meeting had been called in the ‘holiday season’ the committee had considered that members unable to attend should also be consulted and given the opportunity to vote in absentia.
PT went on to say that the club is affiliated to the WBU and had been for ten years and gave a number of examples of benefits arising from that membership, both for the club & for the game of bridge. He also mentioned the prospect of assistance in funding equipment for the club.
PT continued that there were two proposals to be considered at the SGM, one unanimously endorsed by the club committee for continuing affiliation to the WBU with provision for current members who do not wish to become WBU members to be able to continue playing at the club as social players. The club secretary, Peter Smith (PS) would be summarising this proposal when PT had finished his remarks. The second proposal put forward by Stewart Anderton (SA) and supported by Tony Vickers was to split the club into two separate but linked clubs. SA was to summarise his proposals after PS had spoken.
PT stated that as far as practicable all members had been made aware of both proposals and asked for their views and that because of this it was not possible to consider further proposals at the SGM. A third proposal (for the formation of a ‘Wednesdays only’ club) had been put forward on Friday 19th August but could not be considered due to lack of time for consultation, but nothing prevents such a proposal being put at the AGM in October. Notwithstanding that, one of the two proposals before the SGM needed to be approved at the SGM. As the two proposals tabled were contradictory it was not possible to vote in favour of both but voting against both was possible. Because of the prior consultation amendments at the SGM were not possible.
After PT had concluded his presentation a number of points came from the floor of the meeting.
Gail Jones asked why there were only male committee members at the table with the Chairman. PT explained that there was no underlying reason for this and some of the female committee members gave their views.
Jean Edwards (JE) said that she had not seen all the papers circulating prior to the meeting. PT explained that all members not using e mail had been contacted by a member of the committee so that they were not disadvantaged and that he had spoken to Reg Edwards. Jenny Vickers mentioned that Sheila Bateman had not received the second proposal but PS said that he had had a conversation with her during which she expressed her support for the committee and that she was for the committee’s proposal.
PS then outlined the proposal that had been endorsed by the committee, but first said that the committee were fully aware that some members were against joining the WBU, but that the proposal would enable such players to continue playing. He went on to look at each point in turn mentioning also the rising membership of the club and the relatively inexpensive costs of playing at CABC when compared to other clubs. He drew attention to the fact that the proposal gave the opportunity for social players to have a voice in the future running of the club and that social players could put themselves forward as the contact. He drew attention to the fact that only existing club members could qualify as social players and those wishing to become social players should inform the secretary by 30th November 2016.
PS said that there had been a fair amount of response to the proposal and that the committee would bear in mind comments received. He took the opportunity to mention that he and other long standing members of the committee would be standing down in the near future and thanked several non-committee members for their help in the running of the club.
After PS had finished his presentation further points came from the floor.
Gail Jones said that if the proposal for social members had included a payment of £2 table money she would have supported the committee’s motion but would not support it as it stood.
Jean Edwards mentioned the possibility of a Wednesday’s only club.
Steve Dobney (SD) then raised a number of points. He began by referring to proposed social members but PT interjected to stress that they would be social players and not members of the club. SD queried the inability of social players to comment on the expenditure of club funds. SD also asked about representation at the WBU to which PT responded that all WBU members can have an input to WBU decisions and the WBU were actively looking for members that would help in the running etc of the WBU. PS also stated that there were four regions within the WBU and that CABC were invited to contribute to our region (EWBA) in various ways.
Bridget Evans gave her opinion of the benefits of the WBU and said that she considered £10 was cheap for the benefits membership gave her.
PT then outlined some of the benefits of the WBU and Marion Shewell (MS) mentioned that the WBU encouraged bridge to be introduced to primary schools. PS added that bridge in schools was believed to raise the standard of schoolwork. PS went on to say that he used WBU information for training sessions. MS added that the WBU provided advice on dealing with behavior problems in clubs.
Stewart Anderton (SA) then gave a presentation of his proposal, first giving his reasons for providing the alternative including his views on the WBU’s requirements and it’s website. He outlined his proposal to have two separate but closely linked clubs and the relationship between them. The new club (CAWBC) would be formed at the CABC AGM. It would be affiliated to the WBU with all members also being members of the WBU and CABC (and pay CABC fees accordingly). CAWBC would have no membership fees. CAWBC would have a secretary. The rules of the CABC would be amended to require that the Chairman is a member of the WBU. The CABC committee would administer all aspects of CAWBC with the exception of competition/league administration and WBU liaison. New CABC members would be encouraged to join CAWBC. CABC members attending club training events would be WBU members. Any changes to CABC rules/constitution would be handled in the usual fashion by the committee/AGM.
SA concluded by outlining the pros and cons of his proposal. Pros being clarity for the future; minimal change for club members; protection for CABC members against future WBU fee increase; a means of satisfying WBU that CAWBU comply with their requirements. Cons were that the proposal may not satisfy WBU requirements; CAWBC members will no longer be playing under the name of CABC; CABC rules/constitution would need to be revised; CAWBC rules and constitution would need to be drawn up; extra administration.
Marilyn Bond asked SA what would happen to club assets to which SA replied that they would stay with CABC.
Other points then came from the floor.
Chris Ballard asked why costs accruing from WBU membership could not be met from increased table money but PT pointed out that it was too late for new proposals to be considered but they could be considered at the AGM if presented in time.
Grace Martyn raised various issues about how SA’s proposal would deal with specific requirements of the WBU. SA replied that he considered such issues would be dealt with by ‘fine tuning’ the proposals. PT pointed out that there were items in both proposals that would need ‘fine tuning’.
Jean Edwards thought that more discussion was needed but PT said considerations beyond the two proposals could not be discussed as notice had not been given.
Brandon Waters congratulated the committee on their hard work, said that standards in the club were rising and appealed to the meeting to support the committee.
PT then asked for votes in favour of the first (committee endorsed) proposal. Including votes cast before the meeting 57 were in favour out of a total of 90 club members. PT stated that under the club constitution only a simple majority was required, so the committee proposal was accepted. PT then put it to SA that there should be no vote on his proposal for reasons given at the start of the meeting and SA agreed.
PT once again said that any member can propose anything at the AGM providing the club rules and constitution were complied with and stressed that the committee were there to listen to the members.
Brian Harden thanked the committee for their efforts and the meeting was closed by the Chairman.
Top of Page
Minutes of the Annual General Meeting held on 29th October 2015
Apologies for absence:Rosemary Allen, Sue Blake, Margaret Anstey, Nick and Marion Jones, Jack and Marina Hunter, Mary Shapland, Harry and Helen Street, Bridget Evans, Marilyn Bond, Graham Eele, Hugh Green, Barbara Lenthall, John Martyn, Rosemary Seymour-Millington, Margaret Bennett, George Smith, Chris Gosling, Peggy Sadler, Glad Williams
Minutes of AGM 23rd October 2014: Agreed
Matters Arising: Peter advised that the system of finding partners hadn’t been successful and we had reverted to Pat and Brandon being the points of contact. Ian said he was very grateful to them for this service and it was much appreciated by all present.
Chairman’s Report: Peter advised that it had been a very good year for the Club. The number of members had increased to 90 as a result of the classes held last Autumn. We had been able to purchase a new set of Bridgemates and disposed of the old ones to Newnham Bridge Club. We had a series of charity events via which £770 was raised, principally for Children in Need. Both the Summer and Xmas parties ran well and the recent practice of light refreshments provided by the Club seemed to work better. Rosemary and Christine were retiring from the Committee after many years service and the meeting acknowledged their contribution to the running of the Club. Peter advised that the Club’s 40th Anniversary would fall on 23rd September 2016 and we will be considering how this should best be celebrated.
Treasurer’s report: Marion circulated the audited accounts and stated that they now showed a greater breakdown of the miscellaneous expenses. The Club was in a healthy financial state, even after the purchase of the new bridgemates, so she was proposing no change to table money or annual subs at this stage. She advised that the Club had made a loss (considering rent and prize money) on 11 occasions in the last 12 months – 10 on a Wednesday night, and 1 on a Thursday. In response to a question from Stewart, Marion advised that the new bridgemates would depreciate in value by 25% per annum. The motion to adopt the accounts was proposed by Grace and seconded by Carolyne. All agreed
Appointment of auditor for 2015/2016 Hugh Green was prepared to continue in this role and all agreed.
Appointment of Officers: The existing members – Peter Taylor, Marion Shewell, Peter Smith, Graham Eele, John Whiteside, Sue Blake were willing to continue. Nominations were received on behalf of Carolyne Ogden, John Mayo, and Ian Wood to replace Rosemary Allen and Christine Brierley, who were retiring. Steve suggested that as we had 3 willing offers of help we should appoint all 3. This was agreed unanimously.
Possible purchase of a Dealing Machine: Peter said that he had been asked by a number of members about purchasing a dealing machine. The cost would be in the region of £2500. There were offers that we could have one for 12 months and return at the end of the period with a full refund. He had spoken to a number of Clubs who all thought it benefited those at all levels of play who were keen to improve their results. John asked about a cheaper model, the Handy Dup device, but Peter advised that, when more details were given, it would be not a practical option.
Greg was aware of a company who would defer payments over 2 years, this could be considered to reduce the impact on any year’s balance sheet.
The meeting were content that the Committee investigate further – options of individual contributions by some members to reduce the outlay of the Club funds will be considered. Marjorie Tyrrell raised whether dealing of the hands by those who came early wasnt good enough to get random hands, but it was felt the computer hands were more challenging as had more varied distribution, and provided hand records. The Committee was asked by Gail to advise all members of progress in this matter.
Motions to the AGM:
Pat said that she thought that the Committee should arrange more social and other functions on Mondays and Wednesdays, when Thursday seemed to be the normal night. The meeting concurred and Peter advised that the Committee would bear this in mind when scheduling events.
Any Other Business:
1) Chris Ballard suggested we have more team events, and Ian asked about entering a third team in the East Wales league. Peter agreed that it did seem that team events were popular – the Summer party was a success and the Committee will look at this. Pete advised that he had little response to a request in the summer to participate and run a 3rd team but was willing to help set a team up if the demand could be proven.
2) The issue of handicapped scoring and results was raised by Sue Blake. Peter reminded the meeting that this had been discussed at the last 2 AGMs. Pete said he was in favour as it would give a better distribution of the prize money, but the meeting was divided as to the merits. Peter said he would investigate it further and will be discussed at Committee. To have meaningful handicaps however, all results should count, and with no results input for Wednesday nights, this was an issue.
3) Christine was presented with 2 bottles of wine for her committee service, Marion will give 2 bottles to Rosemary for the same reason, when she returns from holiday.
The meeting closed at 7.10 pm with 35 members present.
Top of Page
Minutes of the Annual General Meeting held on 17th October 2013
Apologise for absence:
Mary Shapland, Reg & Jean Edwards, Peggy Sadler, Rosemary Allen, Nick and Marion Jones, John Mayo, Glad Williams, Doreen Griffiths, Meredith Reynolds, Sheila Bateman, Sue Blake, John Whiteside, Marjorie Tyrrell, Rosemary Millington, Margaret Bennett, Harry Street, Peter Baumgardt.
Minutes of AGM 25th October 2012
A minute’s silence was held in memory of the Stuart Butler who was recently a member of the Club and who passed away earlier this year. Brandon considered that during his four years as Chairman the Club had made significant progress. Members of the club had done well in East Wales and Gwent Bridge Academy championships and the special party and charity nights were all signs the club developing. It was a much more welcoming club now and incidents of bad behaviour were far rarer than before.
He was grateful for the support he had received, particularly from Marion as treasurer, but the committee as a whole, and others had also contributed to making his tenure that more enjoyable and less stressful.
The audited accounts report was circulated. Marion pointed out that the accounts were healthy and was proposing no change in annual subscriptions or table money. The number of members was 75 and 19 have been members for at least 20 years. Table numbers were slightly down with losses sustained on 13 occasions – 1 on a Monday, 8 on a Wednesday, and 4 on a Thursday during the year.
Supplies of stationery were good but a new laptop may have to be purchased in the near future. 12 second hand bridgemates had been purchased for £10 each, and these should suffice for a period until a new set was required.
Marion then thanked Brandon for his support whilst he was Chairman and advised that during that time £2611 had been raised by the Club for Charity events. The generosity of the Club had been remarked upon throughout the East Wales bridge area.She then presented Brandon with a case of 6 bottles of wine to acknowledge his contribution to the Club. The 2012/2013 accounts were adopted by a Gail Jones seconded by Carolyne Ogden and all agreed.
Appointment of auditor for 2013/2014 – William Bebbington was willing to do this for another year. This was proposed, seconded and agreed.
Appointment of Officers:
Marion Jones and Brandon Waters retired from the committee. Peter Taylor was nominated and agreed as Chairman. At this point Brandon rapidly left the Chair and Peter assumed it. All other existing members were nominated and all agreed. To replace Marion and Brandon, nominations were received from Sue Blake and Graham Eele. All agreed.
The Monmouth matches had proved popular as it had with those members who had entered various EWBA competitions. Peter Smioth sought the views of the meeting as to whether we should consider running some events with the Club. This was overwhelmingly welcomed – random teams rather than picking your own team mates was recommended, and will be considered at the new Committee’s first meeting on 14th November.
Peter Taylor introduced this item after circulating a paper explaining pros and cons. He said that he was grateful that the glitches with the system had been ironed out by Greg and should not recur. There was a good deal of discussion with slightly more speaking against the proposal than for it. There was a view that it was not necessary to award prize money and have a reduced subscription or table money. The Committee will take these views into account when deciding whether to proceed.
Any Other Business:
Brandon thought we should try and encourage new members by offering lessons rather than sending prospective players to U3A or Newport. The idea of having slower play to help beginners on specific nights was thought would encourage those who were daunted at playing at the Club, or who were put off by past reputation. The Committee will consider this in more detail.
The meeting closed at 7.00 pm with 36 members present.
Top of Page
Minutes of the Annual General Meeting held on 23rd October 2014
Note these draft minutes have been updated following concerns raised by attendees. The minutes remain at draft status until approved at the next AGM
Apologies for absence:Rosemary Allen, John Mayo, Sue Blake, John Whiteside, Gail Jones, Pat and Brandon Waters, Margaret Anstey, Stewart Anderton , Nick and Marion Jones, Jack and Marina Hunter, Sheila Bateman, Meredith Reynolds, Margaret Bennett, Val and George Smith, Tony Waters, Mary Shapland.
Minutes of AGM 17th 2013:Agreed
Pete Smith reported in relation to the last item that beginners’ classes had begun and attendance was good. Steve Dobney queried whether there had been any progress on handicap scoring. The Chair said that there had been none as a consequence of the feelings expressed at the last AGM, but could be implemented if there was now a wish to do so. There was no support expressed for this introduction from other members.
Peter Taylor welcomed Herbie Rowley, President of the WBU, and member of the Archway Club to the meeting. He said that his first year as Chairman had a mixture of achievements and disappointments, with the former outweighing the latter. He was grateful for the support of other members of the Committee and gave commendation to Grace for her progress on using the computer scoring system. He knew the profile of the Club was increasing and he was particularly pleased we were able to enter a second team in the East Wales League.
He raised a particular area of concern – misboarding, which happened quite frequently, and the problems (scoring/incomplete results) that follow from that. This seems to be most common when the board in play is removed from the table. It was agreed that the board in play could be moved to the side of the table but the orientation should never be altered.
For the future, there would be expenditure on a new computer and Bridgemate system, and the Committee would need to decide when such an outlay was necessary.
Marion Shewell advised the accounts were healthy and circulated a copy of the audited accounts. There were currently 74 members. There was currently £6194 in the building society account, but advised that the rent had increased and other costs were in the pipeline. She was not recommending any changes to annual subscriptions or table money. The Club had made a financial loss on 12 nights during the last 12 months – 2 on a Monday, 8 on a Wednesday, 2 on a Thursday.
She advised that due to personal circumstances, William Bebbington had to withdraw from the Auditor role but she was grateful that Hugh Green had volunteered to stand in. The adoption of the accounts was agreed, proposed by Caroline, seconded by John Martyn
Appointment of auditor for 2014/2015 It was proposed by Bridget, and seconded by Marilyn that Hugh Green should be appointed. All agreed.
Appointment of Officers:
The existing Committee was voted in en bloc, there being no other nominations and all being willing to continue.
Motions to the AGM:
Any Other Business:
1) It was concluded that every effort needed to be made to publicise events, co-ordinating with other parties, and where cancelled to make sure this was conveyed fully, with notices on the Club board. The Secretary said he had over 40 members on group E mail, and asked anyone to let him know theirs if he didn’t already have it.
2) An interest was raised by Ian and Greg about the Club investing in a dealing machine, the cost of which would be £3000+. Both thought it would help beginners and the more serious players. Bridget thought that replacing the computer and Bridgemates was a higher priority. The Chairman agreed that it would be added as an agenda item on the next Committee meeting.
3) There was discussion how those students from the beginners classes would best be integrated into the club when the Course finished. Herbie advised of his experience at his and other clubs in Wales who had similar issues. He found that pairing beginners up with more experienced players worked well, as well as making nights more of a social occasion with refreshment breaks.
The Chairman agreed that this was important, which relied on the co-operation of existing members and is to be considered at the next Committee.
4) There was a discussion around a better way of matching players looking for a game while their regular partner was away or unwell. Clearly using the Website had not worked. Jenny suggested putting a notice/rolling programme on the Club notice board where individuals could indicate the nights they were looking for a partner and this will be raised at the next Committee meeting.
The meeting closed at 7.05 pm with 29 members present.
Top of Page
Looking for a playing partner
Brandon and Pat have very generously agreed to continue to act as the focal point for people looking for a playing partnerr when their normal partner is unavailable or indisposed for any reason.
They can be contacted on 01633 272638
Top of Page
Claret Cup 2017;
This year 17 pairs competed for the Claret Cup, which followed on from the 2017 AGM on Monday 30th October. This year, the event was won by Hugh and Carolyne with a score of 68%.
Top of Page